Home

Grocery & Gourmet Food

Pantry Staples

Nut & Seed Butters

Peanut Butter

Filter By

Price

Under $50

$50 To $100

$100 To $200

$200 & Above

Under $50
$50 To $100
$100 To $200
$200 & Above

Brand

Nuts 'N More

American Dream

Heinz|KRAFT HEINZ FS DRY|HEINZ

FLAVORED PB CO.|Flavored PB Co.

Peanut Butter & Co|peanut butter and co|PEANUT BUTTER |Peanut Butter & Co.|Peanut Butter & Co

Generic|Pintola|Genie India

Once Again|ONCE AGAIN

COCOMO|Does not apply

ASS KICKIN'

Professor Nutz

Peanut Butter & Co.|Peanut Butter & Co

Once Again Nut Butter, Inc.|ONCE AGAIN|Does not apply|Ali|Once Again

Big Hawaiian Flowers|TJ's

Peter Pan|KMWA|Does not apply

Busuna|Peter Pan

Reese's|"Reese's"

PB2 Foods|PB2

Visit the Atkins Store|Unbranded|Atkins

Once Again|ONCE AGAIN|Once Again Nut Butter, Inc.|Once Again Nut Butter Collective|Does not apply

Peanut Butter & Co.|Peanut Butter & Co

Trail Butter

PRIME GRADE|Jif

Earth Balance

Betty Lou's|"Betty Lou's"

Jif|BevMo!|Generic

PB2 Foods|Bell Plantation|PB2|Does Not Apply

"JUSTIN'S DRY"|"Justin's"|Justins

Crazy Richard's|Crazy Richard’s|"Crazy Richard's"

"M&M'S"|L.A.N.Y Outlet|M&M's|"M&M's"|Mars|M&M'S

REESE|"Reese's"|Reese's

Does not apply|Unbranded|PB2

Skippy|SKIPPY

Peanut Butter & Co|Peanut Butter & Co.

Jif

Nuts 'N More
American Dream
Heinz|KRAFT HEINZ FS DRY|HEINZ
FLAVORED PB CO.|Flavored PB Co.
Peanut Butter & Co|peanut butter and co|PEANUT BUTTER |Peanut Butter & Co.|Peanut Butter & Co
Generic|Pintola|Genie India
Once Again|ONCE AGAIN
COCOMO|Does not apply
ASS KICKIN'
Professor Nutz
Peanut Butter & Co.|Peanut Butter & Co
Once Again Nut Butter, Inc.|ONCE AGAIN|Does not apply|Ali|Once Again
Big Hawaiian Flowers|TJ's
Peter Pan|KMWA|Does not apply
Busuna|Peter Pan
Better Body Foods|PBfit All-Natural|PBFit|BETTER BODY BRAND|Does not apply|Branded|Unbranded|Better Body Foods, PBfit|PBfit
KRAFT|TrendnSave Canadian Grocery|Kraft Heinz Canada ULC|Kraft|Kraft Heinz|Generic
Reese's|"Reese's"
Unbranded|BetterBody Foods|Does not apply|PB Fit|OTC|unbranded|PBfit|PBFIT
Kirkland Signature|Kirkland|Generic|Unknown|KIRKLAND|ODI Ventures
PB2 Foods|PB2
Visit the Atkins Store|Unbranded|Atkins
"Reese's"|Reese's|HERSHEY'S|Hershey's|REESE'S|"REESE'S"
Once Again|ONCE AGAIN|Once Again Nut Butter, Inc.|Once Again Nut Butter Collective|Does not apply
Peanut Butter & Co.|Peanut Butter & Co
Trail Butter
PRIME GRADE|Jif
Earth Balance
Betty Lou's|"Betty Lou's"
Jif|BevMo!|Generic
PB2 Foods|Bell Plantation|PB2|Does Not Apply
"JUSTIN'S DRY"|"Justin's"|Justins
Crazy Richard's|Crazy Richard’s|"Crazy Richard's"
"M&M'S"|L.A.N.Y Outlet|M&M's|"M&M's"|Mars|M&M'S
REESE|"Reese's"|Reese's
Does not apply|Unbranded|PB2
Skippy|SKIPPY
Peanut Butter & Co|Peanut Butter & Co.
Jif

Filters

Price

Under $50

$50 To $100

$100 To $200

$200 & Above

Under $50
$50 To $100
$100 To $200
$200 & Above

Brand

Nuts 'N More

American Dream

Heinz|KRAFT HEINZ FS DRY|HEINZ

FLAVORED PB CO.|Flavored PB Co.

Peanut Butter & Co|peanut butter and co|PEANUT BUTTER |Peanut Butter & Co.|Peanut Butter & Co

Generic|Pintola|Genie India

Once Again|ONCE AGAIN

COCOMO|Does not apply

ASS KICKIN'

Professor Nutz

Peanut Butter & Co.|Peanut Butter & Co

Once Again Nut Butter, Inc.|ONCE AGAIN|Does not apply|Ali|Once Again

Big Hawaiian Flowers|TJ's

Peter Pan|KMWA|Does not apply

Busuna|Peter Pan

Reese's|"Reese's"

PB2 Foods|PB2

Visit the Atkins Store|Unbranded|Atkins

Once Again|ONCE AGAIN|Once Again Nut Butter, Inc.|Once Again Nut Butter Collective|Does not apply

Peanut Butter & Co.|Peanut Butter & Co

Trail Butter

PRIME GRADE|Jif

Earth Balance

Betty Lou's|"Betty Lou's"

Jif|BevMo!|Generic

PB2 Foods|Bell Plantation|PB2|Does Not Apply

"JUSTIN'S DRY"|"Justin's"|Justins

Crazy Richard's|Crazy Richard’s|"Crazy Richard's"

"M&M'S"|L.A.N.Y Outlet|M&M's|"M&M's"|Mars|M&M'S

REESE|"Reese's"|Reese's

Does not apply|Unbranded|PB2

Skippy|SKIPPY

Peanut Butter & Co|Peanut Butter & Co.

Jif

Nuts 'N More
American Dream
Heinz|KRAFT HEINZ FS DRY|HEINZ
FLAVORED PB CO.|Flavored PB Co.
Peanut Butter & Co|peanut butter and co|PEANUT BUTTER |Peanut Butter & Co.|Peanut Butter & Co
Generic|Pintola|Genie India
Once Again|ONCE AGAIN
COCOMO|Does not apply
ASS KICKIN'
Professor Nutz
Peanut Butter & Co.|Peanut Butter & Co
Once Again Nut Butter, Inc.|ONCE AGAIN|Does not apply|Ali|Once Again
Big Hawaiian Flowers|TJ's
Peter Pan|KMWA|Does not apply
Busuna|Peter Pan
Better Body Foods|PBfit All-Natural|PBFit|BETTER BODY BRAND|Does not apply|Branded|Unbranded|Better Body Foods, PBfit|PBfit
KRAFT|TrendnSave Canadian Grocery|Kraft Heinz Canada ULC|Kraft|Kraft Heinz|Generic
Reese's|"Reese's"
Unbranded|BetterBody Foods|Does not apply|PB Fit|OTC|unbranded|PBfit|PBFIT
Kirkland Signature|Kirkland|Generic|Unknown|KIRKLAND|ODI Ventures
PB2 Foods|PB2
Visit the Atkins Store|Unbranded|Atkins
"Reese's"|Reese's|HERSHEY'S|Hershey's|REESE'S|"REESE'S"
Once Again|ONCE AGAIN|Once Again Nut Butter, Inc.|Once Again Nut Butter Collective|Does not apply
Peanut Butter & Co.|Peanut Butter & Co
Trail Butter
PRIME GRADE|Jif
Earth Balance
Betty Lou's|"Betty Lou's"
Jif|BevMo!|Generic
PB2 Foods|Bell Plantation|PB2|Does Not Apply
"JUSTIN'S DRY"|"Justin's"|Justins
Crazy Richard's|Crazy Richard’s|"Crazy Richard's"
"M&M'S"|L.A.N.Y Outlet|M&M's|"M&M's"|Mars|M&M'S
REESE|"Reese's"|Reese's
Does not apply|Unbranded|PB2
Skippy|SKIPPY
Peanut Butter & Co|Peanut Butter & Co.
Jif

Filter By

Price

Under $50

$50 To $100

$100 To $200

$200 & Above

Under $50
$50 To $100
$100 To $200
$200 & Above

Brand

Nuts 'N More

American Dream

Heinz|KRAFT HEINZ FS DRY|HEINZ

FLAVORED PB CO.|Flavored PB Co.

Peanut Butter & Co|peanut butter and co|PEANUT BUTTER |Peanut Butter & Co.|Peanut Butter & Co

Generic|Pintola|Genie India

Once Again|ONCE AGAIN

COCOMO|Does not apply

ASS KICKIN'

Professor Nutz

Peanut Butter & Co.|Peanut Butter & Co

Once Again Nut Butter, Inc.|ONCE AGAIN|Does not apply|Ali|Once Again

Big Hawaiian Flowers|TJ's

Peter Pan|KMWA|Does not apply

Busuna|Peter Pan

Reese's|"Reese's"

PB2 Foods|PB2

Visit the Atkins Store|Unbranded|Atkins

Once Again|ONCE AGAIN|Once Again Nut Butter, Inc.|Once Again Nut Butter Collective|Does not apply

Peanut Butter & Co.|Peanut Butter & Co

Trail Butter

PRIME GRADE|Jif

Earth Balance

Betty Lou's|"Betty Lou's"

Jif|BevMo!|Generic

PB2 Foods|Bell Plantation|PB2|Does Not Apply

"JUSTIN'S DRY"|"Justin's"|Justins

Crazy Richard's|Crazy Richard’s|"Crazy Richard's"

"M&M'S"|L.A.N.Y Outlet|M&M's|"M&M's"|Mars|M&M'S

REESE|"Reese's"|Reese's

Does not apply|Unbranded|PB2

Skippy|SKIPPY

Peanut Butter & Co|Peanut Butter & Co.

Jif

Nuts 'N More
American Dream
Heinz|KRAFT HEINZ FS DRY|HEINZ
FLAVORED PB CO.|Flavored PB Co.
Peanut Butter & Co|peanut butter and co|PEANUT BUTTER |Peanut Butter & Co.|Peanut Butter & Co
Generic|Pintola|Genie India
Once Again|ONCE AGAIN
COCOMO|Does not apply
ASS KICKIN'
Professor Nutz
Peanut Butter & Co.|Peanut Butter & Co
Once Again Nut Butter, Inc.|ONCE AGAIN|Does not apply|Ali|Once Again
Big Hawaiian Flowers|TJ's
Peter Pan|KMWA|Does not apply
Busuna|Peter Pan
Better Body Foods|PBfit All-Natural|PBFit|BETTER BODY BRAND|Does not apply|Branded|Unbranded|Better Body Foods, PBfit|PBfit
KRAFT|TrendnSave Canadian Grocery|Kraft Heinz Canada ULC|Kraft|Kraft Heinz|Generic
Reese's|"Reese's"
Unbranded|BetterBody Foods|Does not apply|PB Fit|OTC|unbranded|PBfit|PBFIT
Kirkland Signature|Kirkland|Generic|Unknown|KIRKLAND|ODI Ventures
PB2 Foods|PB2
Visit the Atkins Store|Unbranded|Atkins
"Reese's"|Reese's|HERSHEY'S|Hershey's|REESE'S|"REESE'S"
Once Again|ONCE AGAIN|Once Again Nut Butter, Inc.|Once Again Nut Butter Collective|Does not apply
Peanut Butter & Co.|Peanut Butter & Co
Trail Butter
PRIME GRADE|Jif
Earth Balance
Betty Lou's|"Betty Lou's"
Jif|BevMo!|Generic
PB2 Foods|Bell Plantation|PB2|Does Not Apply
"JUSTIN'S DRY"|"Justin's"|Justins
Crazy Richard's|Crazy Richard’s|"Crazy Richard's"
"M&M'S"|L.A.N.Y Outlet|M&M's|"M&M's"|Mars|M&M'S
REESE|"Reese's"|Reese's
Does not apply|Unbranded|PB2
Skippy|SKIPPY
Peanut Butter & Co|Peanut Butter & Co.
Jif

Filters

Price

Under $50

$50 To $100

$100 To $200

$200 & Above

Under $50
$50 To $100
$100 To $200
$200 & Above

Brand

Nuts 'N More

American Dream

Heinz|KRAFT HEINZ FS DRY|HEINZ

FLAVORED PB CO.|Flavored PB Co.

Peanut Butter & Co|peanut butter and co|PEANUT BUTTER |Peanut Butter & Co.|Peanut Butter & Co

Generic|Pintola|Genie India

Once Again|ONCE AGAIN

COCOMO|Does not apply

ASS KICKIN'

Professor Nutz

Peanut Butter & Co.|Peanut Butter & Co

Once Again Nut Butter, Inc.|ONCE AGAIN|Does not apply|Ali|Once Again

Big Hawaiian Flowers|TJ's

Peter Pan|KMWA|Does not apply

Busuna|Peter Pan

Reese's|"Reese's"

PB2 Foods|PB2

Visit the Atkins Store|Unbranded|Atkins

Once Again|ONCE AGAIN|Once Again Nut Butter, Inc.|Once Again Nut Butter Collective|Does not apply

Peanut Butter & Co.|Peanut Butter & Co

Trail Butter

PRIME GRADE|Jif

Earth Balance

Betty Lou's|"Betty Lou's"

Jif|BevMo!|Generic

PB2 Foods|Bell Plantation|PB2|Does Not Apply

"JUSTIN'S DRY"|"Justin's"|Justins

Crazy Richard's|Crazy Richard’s|"Crazy Richard's"

"M&M'S"|L.A.N.Y Outlet|M&M's|"M&M's"|Mars|M&M'S

REESE|"Reese's"|Reese's

Does not apply|Unbranded|PB2

Skippy|SKIPPY

Peanut Butter & Co|Peanut Butter & Co.

Jif

Nuts 'N More
American Dream
Heinz|KRAFT HEINZ FS DRY|HEINZ
FLAVORED PB CO.|Flavored PB Co.
Peanut Butter & Co|peanut butter and co|PEANUT BUTTER |Peanut Butter & Co.|Peanut Butter & Co
Generic|Pintola|Genie India
Once Again|ONCE AGAIN
COCOMO|Does not apply
ASS KICKIN'
Professor Nutz
Peanut Butter & Co.|Peanut Butter & Co
Once Again Nut Butter, Inc.|ONCE AGAIN|Does not apply|Ali|Once Again
Big Hawaiian Flowers|TJ's
Peter Pan|KMWA|Does not apply
Busuna|Peter Pan
Better Body Foods|PBfit All-Natural|PBFit|BETTER BODY BRAND|Does not apply|Branded|Unbranded|Better Body Foods, PBfit|PBfit
KRAFT|TrendnSave Canadian Grocery|Kraft Heinz Canada ULC|Kraft|Kraft Heinz|Generic
Reese's|"Reese's"
Unbranded|BetterBody Foods|Does not apply|PB Fit|OTC|unbranded|PBfit|PBFIT
Kirkland Signature|Kirkland|Generic|Unknown|KIRKLAND|ODI Ventures
PB2 Foods|PB2
Visit the Atkins Store|Unbranded|Atkins
"Reese's"|Reese's|HERSHEY'S|Hershey's|REESE'S|"REESE'S"
Once Again|ONCE AGAIN|Once Again Nut Butter, Inc.|Once Again Nut Butter Collective|Does not apply
Peanut Butter & Co.|Peanut Butter & Co
Trail Butter
PRIME GRADE|Jif
Earth Balance
Betty Lou's|"Betty Lou's"
Jif|BevMo!|Generic
PB2 Foods|Bell Plantation|PB2|Does Not Apply
"JUSTIN'S DRY"|"Justin's"|Justins
Crazy Richard's|Crazy Richard’s|"Crazy Richard's"
"M&M'S"|L.A.N.Y Outlet|M&M's|"M&M's"|Mars|M&M'S
REESE|"Reese's"|Reese's
Does not apply|Unbranded|PB2
Skippy|SKIPPY
Peanut Butter & Co|Peanut Butter & Co.
Jif

Nuts ‘N More Cinnamon Toast Peanut Butter Powder, All Natural Keto Snack, Low ...

$17.23

Compare at 3 stores

American Dream Gluten-Free Thicka Than a Snicka Peanut Butter

$14.99

Compare at 6 stores

Heinz 0.75 oz. Peanut Butter Portion Cups - 200/Case

$94.58

Compare at 10 stores

Flavored PB Co. Peanut Butter Powder, Low carb and Only 45 calories

$11.04

Compare at 5 stores

Peanut Butter & Co, White Chocolate Wonderful Flavored Peanut Butter Spread, 16 oz., 6 Pack

$46.97

Compare at 94 stores

Pintola High Protein Dark Chocolate Creamy Peanut Butter - 1 kg

$39.6

Compare at 9 stores

Once Again - Peanut Butter Creamy No Salt - 1 Each 1-5 Lb

$43.34

Compare at 10 stores

Cocomo Coconut Peanut Butter

$35.99

Compare at 9 stores

PB2 Peanut Butter Powdered

$8.29

Compare at 5 stores

Ass Kickin Peanut Butter Flavor Habanero Net Wt 13 Oz

$11.7

Compare at 3 stores

Professor nut Salty Caramel

$15.99

Compare at 10 stores

Peanut Butter & Co. Peanut Butter Spread

$29.67

Compare at 12 stores

Once Again Natural, Creamy Peanut Butter, 9lb Bucket (same as 9 jars) - Salt Free, Unsweetened - Gluten Free Certified, Vegan, Kosher, Non-GMO Verified

$39.99

Compare at 51 stores